beta-boy
Member
- Joined
- Apr 26, 2012
- Messages
- 136
I thought it might be helpful to have a thread dedicated to the exchange of information concerning safety and privacy when it comes doing business with the vendors in this section.
The recent thread about hushmail made me rethink my own practices. I had been thinking about creating a tormail.org account for some time now and only recently got around to actually doing it.
However, I also decided to do some research about the actual safety and security of tormail and ran into some unsettling information.
I went ahead and posted that information in the hushmail thread and I'll copy it here so folks who didn't see it don't have to jump over there:
After I posted this, I noticed someone else came into the thread and said that tormail is the best mail server to use in terms of privacy. However, I am still concerned about this whole issue of exit nodes. I would love to hear from anyone more tech savvy than I ... or anyone who has more specific information about this issue. At the moment, I am leaning toward using gmail and creating a new email IDs every so often.
Obviously, as someone already mentioned in the hushmail thread, the best practice would be to use an OpenPGP encrypted email server. But it doesn't seem like the vendors are willing to go this route. (Actually, the very best practice would be to create your own email server that gets routed through another country ... something I don't have anywhere near enough expertise to pull off.)
_________________________________________
Then, of course, there is the email content side of the issue. And to that point I posted this:
So ... if anyone is willing to share some of their safe practices ... or if anyone has any questions ... or if anyone has any information or past experiences with various email servers ... this thread is the place.
Again ... if people don't feel comfortable replying directly here in the thread, they can certainly direct message an answer or question.
The recent thread about hushmail made me rethink my own practices. I had been thinking about creating a tormail.org account for some time now and only recently got around to actually doing it.
However, I also decided to do some research about the actual safety and security of tormail and ran into some unsettling information.
I went ahead and posted that information in the hushmail thread and I'll copy it here so folks who didn't see it don't have to jump over there:
The issue is ... tor and tormail uses other computers to route your browsing traffic or mail through a random series of nodes. That part seems to work just fine and anonymity is virtually guaranteed unless you are being spied on by someone like the NSA.
However, some people claim that the FBI has established a whole bunch of computers to act as "exit nodes" ... i.e. the last node or computer that your email pops out of before reaching its destination. They are called "honeypot" nodes and are used specifically to catch criminal activity because the emails are not encrypted when they leave the exit node.
Now ... the paranoid types claim that the whole Tor network was set-up by the government to be one giant honeypot. (It was originally developed by the Navy.)
But ... more reasonable security people say, Tor is so big that it is unlikely that the FBI could establish more than 20% of the exit nodes as honeypots. And probably it is far less than 20% ... even if they have created honeypot nodes ... which is something that no one has actually confirmed.
That said ... the question becomes ... do you use tormail and run the risk of the long odds of your email being scooped up into an FBI honeypot and it actually being read and acted on ... or ... do you use the power of LARGE NUMBERS by sticking with a basic gmail account ... where you "hide in plain sight" as it were by just being one in several million emails each day? Because Tormail is specifically used by people trying to hide communications ... one can understand how LE might be doing their best to monitor as much of it as they can and might have established these honeypot nodes. Whereas with a basic gmail account, they are literally fishing the entire ocean for a few shrimp and may need a warrant to actually monitor a specific email address.
After I posted this, I noticed someone else came into the thread and said that tormail is the best mail server to use in terms of privacy. However, I am still concerned about this whole issue of exit nodes. I would love to hear from anyone more tech savvy than I ... or anyone who has more specific information about this issue. At the moment, I am leaning toward using gmail and creating a new email IDs every so often.
Obviously, as someone already mentioned in the hushmail thread, the best practice would be to use an OpenPGP encrypted email server. But it doesn't seem like the vendors are willing to go this route. (Actually, the very best practice would be to create your own email server that gets routed through another country ... something I don't have anywhere near enough expertise to pull off.)
_________________________________________
Then, of course, there is the email content side of the issue. And to that point I posted this:
Probably the bigger issue is the content of our emails.
That's something I have not figured out how to get around. To receive an order you have to use a home or work address ... or like I do ... have it shipped to a UPS store. But when you have it shipped to a UPS store, you need to have it sent to you by name so you can pick it up.
If there is a way to have an order shipped to you via store or other means WITHOUT needing to include your name ... that would pretty much solve all/most issues.
If anyone has some tips or suggestions ... would love to hear them. You can respond to me directly with a message if you don't want to post.
So ... if anyone is willing to share some of their safe practices ... or if anyone has any questions ... or if anyone has any information or past experiences with various email servers ... this thread is the place.
Again ... if people don't feel comfortable replying directly here in the thread, they can certainly direct message an answer or question.